Question ID 1852 - 2014-08-15 09:44:40
Question:
While offering salaat, What should be the distance between a Meharm man and woman while the mehram woman prays behind the mehram man
Answer:
His place of standing should be ahead her place of Sajda.
Wassalam.
>
>
Question ID 1853 - 2014-08-16 04:42:21
Question:
Salamun Alaykum Maulana Can you please verify the authenticicity of below narration:- يروى أن عمرو ابن العاص قدم من الإسكندرية على النبي فسأله عما رأى؟ قال : رأيت قوما يتطلسون ويجتمعون حلقا، ويذكرون رجلا يقال له أرسطو طاليس لعنه الله! فقال له النبي: مه يا عمرو!، إن أرسطو طاليس كان نبيا فجهله قومه It is narrated that `Amr bin al-`Āṣ came from Alexandria to the Prophet and he (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) asked him (`Amr) about what he saw? He (`Amr bin al-`Āṣ) said: ‘I saw a group of people would gather in a halaqa, and they would mention a man, they called him Aristotle, may Allāh curse him. Then the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) said to him (`Amr): ‘O `Amr, Aristotle is a Prophet, but his people were ignorant of him! Aristotle repudiated their argument. His answer was that if anything occurs apparently by chance, it too has definite causes which deviate it from its regular activity. That chance is never on the level of natural activity which may continue for ever. (From Tawheed Mufadhal) http://www.al-islam.org/tradition-of-mufaddal-pearls-of-wisdom-from-imam-jafar-as-sadiq/fourth-session-natural-disasters Jazakallah
Answer:
This narration is Not authentic as it has no authentic chain of narrators
to the Prophet (SAWA) and is not found in any of our Shia authentic books
of Hadeeth. It claims that Amr Ibn Al Aas came from Egypt to the Prophet
(SAWA), while the well known fact is he did not go to Egypt but during the
rule of Umar many years after the Prophet (SAWA)'s passing away.
Wassalam.
Mohammad al-Musawi
>
>
Question ID 1854 - 2014-08-16 04:45:22
Question:
Salamun Alaykum Maulana Some of the shia scholors are teaching Irfan/Tassawuf and philosophy of famous Greek philosophers Arusto and Aflatoon in order to attain higher level of spirituality and understanding of God and to be able to debate athiest to prove the existence of God. Is it ok to send our kids to such ulama and their lectures. Jazakllah and Wassalam
Answer:
The teachings of Arusto and Aflatoon which are available today are not the
real truth according to the teachings of the Prophet Muhammed (PBHP)and his
holy Progeny Ahul Bayt (AS). It is wrong to leave the pure teachings of the
Prophet (PBHP) and his holy progeny and go after Greek philosophers or any
other philosophers because philosophers can be right in some areas and
wrong in other areas while the teachings of the Prophet (PBHP) and his
Ahlul Bayt (AS) are always right.
I am sorry to hear that some persons are teaching others the ideas of the
philosophers instead of teaching them the pure and perfect truth from the
sayings of the Prophet (PBHP) and his holy progeny Ahlul Bayt (AS).
Wassalam.
Mohammad al-Musawi.
>
Question ID 1855 - 2014-08-16 07:23:03
Question:
Salam, can a cooked piece of meat be purified by Kur water if it becomes Najis?? Marja Ayatullah Sistani
Answer:
If the meat is Halal, and then got Najis by any najis item, it can be
purified by water. If the meat is not Halal, it will remain Najis always.
Wassalam.
Mohammad al-Musawi
Question ID 1856 - 2014-08-16 09:26:27
Question:
Salaam alaikum syed musawi, I have emailed you my question as i do not want it to be seen on your website. It has been few days i am waiting for your reply. Maybe it has gone in your junk mail please check. Thankyou.
Answer:
Please email it again to wabil@wabil.com
On Fri, Aug 15, 2014 at 9:26 PM, syeda samra haider zaidi <
wabil1895232@wabil.com>Reply-To:
> Mr/Mrs syeda samra haider zaidi
> posted a new question on wabil website, the details are below...
> Category : Family issues
> Question : Salaam alaikum syed musawi,
> I have emailed you my question as i do not want it to be seen on your
> website. It has been few days i am waiting for your reply. Maybe it has
> gone in your junk mail please check.
>
> Thankyou.
>
>