Question ID 2116 - 2014-11-29 07:39:40
Question:
Agar hazrat ali karamullah wajhu ko, hazRat siddiqe akbar se bughz tha tu unhune unke peeche 2 saal namaz kyu ada ki. 2- agar hazrat siddiqe akbar ne khatoone jannat ka haq nahi diya tha tu hazrat ali ke hath main jab khilafat aayei tu unhone unke beton ko maan ka haq kyu nahi diya? Hazrat abu bakr par etbaar nahi hazRat umar par yaqeen nahi hazrat usman par bharosa nahi tu hazrat ali karamullah wajhu ki zaat par tu etmaad hai na aapko . Ye mere 2 sawal iska barahe karam aap jawab de Wasalam Manam az kamtar ghulame ghulamane ahlebait. -haqeer faqeer lareb alvi
Answer:
1. Hazrat Ali (AS) kept patience (Sabr) just to save Islam from civil war
between Muslims which could lead to total collapse of Muslim society.
Hazrat Ali (AS) said openly ( I will not fight against those who took my
right, as far as Muslims are safe and injustice is done only on me.)
You may read Khutba Shaqshaqiyyah to see what hazrat Ali (AS) said.
2. Fadak was given to Hazrat Fatima (AS) by the Prophet (SAWA). Abu bakr
and Umar took it from her. She objected on them in front of Muslims in the
Masjid. Fatima does not say but the truth. Imam Ali (AS) did not take it
back because he did not want to used the government for any personal
benefit. Umar Bin Abdul Aziz gave Fadak back to the children of Hazrat
Fatima.
Wassalam.
Mohammad al-Musawi
>
>
Question ID 2136 - 2014-12-03 02:54:13
Question:
As Salam Alay Kum, There is One quest regarding If I subtract the Khums Amount in every year & I get a Small resource (Poor) Syed family (it has small earning but master dose not fullfill his family need like education,tuntion free and other needs of his children),then Can I give the Khums Amount of Sahme Imam including Sahme Sadat. Plz Guide me for right Path. Wassala...Iltemas e Duaa.
Answer:
Sahm e Sadat can be given to poor Saywda directly with out permission from
the Marja. But Sahm e Imam needs permission from the Marja of Taqleed.
Wassalam
Mohammad Al-Musawi
On Tuesday, December 2, 2014, SYED TAZAKKUR IMAM
> Mr/Mrs SYED TAZAKKUR IMAM
> posted a new question on wabil website, the details are below...
> Category : Zakat and Khums
> Question : As Salam Alay Kum,
>
> There is One quest regarding If I subtract the Khums Amount in every year
> & I get a Small resource (Poor) Syed family (it has small earning but
> master dose not fullfill his family need like education,tuntion free and
> other needs of his children),then Can I give the Khums Amount of Sahme Imam
> including Sahme Sadat.
>
> Plz Guide me for right Path.
>
> Wassala...Iltemas e Duaa.
>
>
Question ID 2137 - 2014-12-03 10:38:59
Question:
Salam un alike 1.is the remembrance of Martyrdom of Imam Hussain A.S and grieving for Him A.S permissible at the end of Salat ? or we must only shed tears for the sake of Allah {SWT} when Praying ? 2.is listning to Quran recitation/Dua/Noha permissible when performing Salat ? Thankyou
Answer:
1. Shedding tears on the tragedies of Ahlul Bayt (AS) during Salaat is
permissible.
2. During Salaat we need to concentrate on our Salaat not on any thing else.
Wassalam.
Mohammad al-Musawi
Question ID 2138 - 2014-12-04 06:16:30
Question:
Is the hades of imams (a.s.) absolute or context bound on the account "of a child BEING born out of zina and that HE will never love Imam Ali (a.s.)"?
Answer:
Not every child born out of marriage will not love Imam Ali (AS), but those
who hate Imam Ali (AS) are either Munafiq or illegitimate.
There are many persons who were born out of marriage still love Allah, the
Prophet (SAWA) and Ahlul Bayt (AS) and do good deeds and then go to
Paradise as a result of their true faith and good deeds..
Wassalam.
Mohammad al-Musawi
>
>
Question ID 2117 - 2014-11-29 17:59:47
Question:
Salam brother, there are two Hadees-e-kisa, short one which can be found through mutawwatir sources in both Shia and Sunni sources and long one that Jabir ibn `Abdullah al-Ansari said that he heard Fatimah the daughter of the Holy Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him and his Household saying so and so. Is the latter one authentic in both its asnad(chains) and matn(content)?
Answer:
Yes, the long Hadeeth al Kisaa which narrated by Jabir Ibn Abdullah
al-Ansari is authentic. It has been narrated by authentic narrators one
after the another till Jabir who is very authentic companion (Sahaabi).
لقد رواه الثقة الجليل الشيخ عبد الله البحراني صاحب كتاب"العوالم" بسندٍ متصل
بثلةٍ جليلة من علماء الطائفة متصلاً بالشيخ الكليني بسند معنعن إلى جابر بن
عبد الله الأنصاري،قال البحراني :"رأيت بخطّ الشيخ الجليل هاشم البحراني عن
شيخه الجليل السيّد ماجد البحراني عن الشيخ الحسن بن زين الدين الشهيد الثاني
العاملي عن شيخه المقدّس الأردبيلي عن شيخه عليّ بن عبد العالي الكركي العاملي
عن الشيخ عليّ بن هلال الجزائري عن الشيخ أحمد بن فهد الحليّ عن الشيخ عليّ بن
الخازن الحائري عن الشيخ ضياء الدين عليّ أبن الشهيد الأول العاملي عن ابيه عن
فخر المحققين عن شيخه المحقق عن شيخه ابن نما الحليّ عن شيخه محمد بن إدريس
الحليّ عن ابن حمزة الطوسي صاحب "ثاقب المناقب" عن الشيخ الجليل محمد بن شهر
آشوب عن الطبرسيّ صاحب الإحتجاج عن شيخه الجليل الحسن بن محمد بن الحسن الطوسي
عن أبيه شيخ الطائفة الحقةعن شيخه المفيد عن شيخه ابن قولويه القمي عن شيخه
الكليني عن عليّ بن إبراهيم عن أبيه إبراهيم بن هاشم عن أحمد بن محمد بن أبي
نصر البزنطي عن قاسم بن يحيى الجلاء الكوفي عن أبي بصير عن أبان بن تغلب عن
جابر بن عبد الله الأنصاري
Wassalam.
Mohammad al-Musawi